Archives‎ > ‎

Term limits? by Mazin Qumsiyeh

Can we have an honest objective discussion of term limits in public life?
It has become common practice to hear people speak about those in office
who are wed to their chair and refuse to let others take over what they
consider to be their position. Whether it is those who have a renewal of
their position like members of the US congress and the senate who became
career politicians by running for elections (no term limits) or those who
are set in a position like a king or perpetual president by virtue of other
arrangements. We find people like Yasser Arafat and Mahmoud Abbas basically
enjoy their acquired positions and age and even die in office. We joke that
we never have a living ex-president in te Arab world. But sometimes it is
easy to pick on politicians when people have much closer examples.
Thousands of non-governmental organizations run by the same person
sometimes for decades. Many academic leadership positions in our
universities seem to have unchanging faces.  There are some who will argue
that experience trumps new blood.  Might it not be good to have the >25
year experience of Saeb Erekat (“Chief Negotiator” and author of “Life is
Negotiations”)? Further, when you do have term-limits, you may still get
the same outcome via other ways. Case in point Bush Jr coming to office of
US President after Bush senior or the impending return to the white house
of the Clintons. And in systems like the Israeli apartheid system or the
American “democracy” does it really matter to common people’s lives whether
it is a leader of one or the other party that takes office? Aren’t there
well known “rulers” (the military-industrial-financial elite circle) that
run the show any way? Or should we take the revolutionary line and vote for
a third party candidate to stir the pot?

Can either Clinton or Trump really take power away from the Federal Reserve
(private bankers who print money at their whim)? Can either of them
stand-up to the Israel lobby that cost tax payers over 6 trillion dollars
and cost hundreds of thousands of deaths? So the question comes to issue of
power and who wields it and for what purpose. Do the people have power to
change things? Would demanding term limits in smaller offices (like
universities and small NGOs) and perhaps also demanding transparency and
accountability and outcomes in these institutions have a ripple effect up
the hierarchy to state and national offices? Some people impose their own
limits on their power and on their positions. But usually those are the
humble ones who get replaced by egotistical individuals.

As I pondered these things it occurred to me that remarkably little
discussion of such matters go on. Discussions must also lead to action. If
the system is rotten, stirring a bit might be the best possible outcome.
Water gets stagnant if it is not stirred and oxygenated. Now the
Palestinians will go to municipal elections. Avigdor Lieberman renewed the
plans of his predecessors of “carrots and sticks” promising collective
punishment for towns which show any signs of resistance and collective
easing of repressive occupation measures for towns that have 100%
compliance. He mentions the town where I was born as a compliant town! Alas
we have much work to do as we challenge not just the occupation but a
system f compliant leadership in towns that have historically been known to
be models of resistance. But the question remain that if you get rid of the
entrenched forces who have been comfortably in office for years, do you
really have good smart, young leadership to take over? And what about youth
and women voices?  Can we afford the change or can we afford not to change?
Considering that Palestine remains under occupation and the situation gets
worse every day (more sellers, more home demolitions etc), what do we have
to lose from trying new things? Isn’t this also true at the global level?
Revolution anyone?

We may want to at least live in dignity and maybe even die in dignity (ala
Vittorio Arrigoni and Rachel Corrie).

Mazin Qumsiyeh
Professor and (volunteer) Director
Palestine Museum of Natural History
Palestine Institute of Biodiversity and Sustainability
Bethlehem University
Occupied Palestine

HumanRights newsletter